Quick Answer

In this section we are going to quickly tell you all the best peanut butter whiskey brands so that those of you that need a quick answer to your question can get it.

1. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Two Trees
2. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Bird Dog
3. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Skrewball
4. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Scatterbrain
5. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Ole Smoky
6. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Sheep Dog
7. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Hard Truth
8. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by PB&W
9. Peanut Butter Whiskey made by Coastal Creek
10. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Copper Still Chocolate
11. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Rams Point
12. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Blind Squirrel
13. P’Nutty Butter Whiskey Made by Shepherd’s
14. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Barrel & Banter
15. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Sqrrl

Which Peanut Butter Whiskey Brands Are The Best?

When you are confronted with a wide range of peanut butter whiskey brands and products it can be hard to know which way to turn. Contrary to popular belief it is not easier to make a decision if there are a LOT of choices.

You just end up sitting there, wondering which one is the right choice.

Below we have found the best peanut butter whiskey drinks out there so that you can peruse the best of the best right here. So, without further ado, let us dive right in and get started! There is a lot to cover!

1. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Two Trees

This brand of alcohol sells nine different flavored whiskeys. But the peanut butter whiskey has an altogether different flavor. It is velvety smooth and the addition of the peanut butter flavor really adds some depth to this beverage.

This whiskey is not aged in traditional barrels. The innovative methods they use allow the whiskey to absorb flavors from peanut butter and other ingredients more effectively. All to make a more delicious flavorful bouquet.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $25 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

2. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Bird Dog

This whiskey is made using aged corn, rye, or even barley bourbon. It is aged in normal oak barrels and somewhere in the process it is infused with a delicious peanut butter flavor.

This brand of peanut butter whiskey has that traditional burn that all whiskey lovers have come to know and love.

But the peanut butter in this alcoholic beverage makes the burn a bit more tolerable which can make this whiskey a bit more tolerable to some people.

On top of all that this Bird Dog whiskey also has a reasonably high alcohol content. It has 40% ABV which is quite impressive.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $18 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

3. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Skrewball

This brand of whiskey came about when a man named Steven Yeng created a Peanut Butter Whiskey drink at his bar in the city of San Diego.

It was so popular that we developed a delicious peanut butter flavored whiskey which he intended to sell to anyone that wanted it.

This tasty drink has a delightful note of caramel and vanilla both of which work wonderfully with the peanut butter flavoring.

One sip of this delectable drink and you will certainly want another.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $29 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

4. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Scatterbrain

This Canadian whiskey brand was only recently made available to the public. While it may look a bit like the Screwball whiskey, it is certainly not the same.

The flavoring has caramel and vanilla notes but it also contains butterscotch which really adds just a little more depth of flavor.

This whiskey has a tinge of sweetness which gives it a bit of an artificial taste. But for those of you that enjoy a sweet bouquet, then this whiskey will be perfect for you.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $19 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

5. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Ole Smoky

The Ole Smoky brand is well-known for their moonshine. Before they made whiskey, they were proudly making and selling other spirits. To make their delicious peanut butter whiskey, they use a two-year corn whiskey base.

This creates a delectable smooth texture with a delicious buttered popcorn, licorice, honey and obviously peanut butter taste.

It really is quite extraordinary to taste. You are bound to love this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $21per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

6. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Sheep Dog

The release of Sheep Dog’s peanut butter whiskey is relatively new on the market. But that does not make it any more delicious. It has quickly become one of the favored drinks sold by this brand.

The caramel, butterscotch and vanilla flavors all work perfectly together with the peanut butter. One sip and you will be hooked!

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $20per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

7. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Hard Truth

This straight bourbon based whiskey has a delightful dark hue. If you compare this peanut butter whiskey with other similar products you will quickly find that it has a bit more of a complex flavor.

The clear oaky notes are perfectly balanced with the sweet yet salty flavors in this whiskey. You will almost certainly finish a bottle faster than you think once you get a taste of this delightful drink.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $32 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

8. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by PB&W

This brand is well known for making a wide variety of delicious alcoholic beverages, but none are as tasty and unique as their peanut butter whiskey. The distillery that makes this whiskey uses their premium whiskey as a base which is why it has such a deliciously potent flavor.

The deep salted peanut butter flavor in his alcohol really is quite splendid. One taste and you will fall in love with this delicious peanut butter whiskey.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $26 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

9. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Coastal Creek

The slightly aged bourbon that Coastal Creek uses to make this delicious whiskey really adds so much depth to their drink. But what we really loved was the scent. It is strong, yet delightful. One sip and you will not be able to put down your glass…or the bottle.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $22 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

10. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Copper Still Chocolate

This delicious peanut butter whiskey is phenomenal. It is infused with hot chocolate and peanut butter to create a heavenly flavor that will certainly get its hooks in you.

Despite the sweetness and complex flavors that this whiskey possesses it does have a harsh burn. But that is part of the fun when you drink this tasty drink.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $21 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

11. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Rams Point

The peanut butter in this whiskey tastes a bit like Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The sweetness and saltiness really makes for a delightful sweet bouquet that you will certainly want more of when you get the chance.

This whiskey in particular has a medium oak appearance which can leave a bit of a bitter taste in your mouth. But if that is something that you enjoy, this drink will be just what you are looking for.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $17 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

12. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Blind Squirrel

This particular brand of whiskey tends to taste less like a liquor and more like a whiskey. The scent that arises from this tasty drink is profound. You will certainly know what you are getting even after one whiff of this whiskey.

It has a delightfully subtle scent of caramel and vanilla which perfectly compliment the peanut butter favors. This combination is utter perfection. One sip and you are bound to agree.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $18 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

13. P’Nutty Butter Whiskey Made By Shepherd’s

The precise flavor that this whiskey drink offers really makes for a distinct yet enjoyable experience. The cherry on top of this alcoholic beverage has to be the perfectly balanced caramel, and vanilla.

Both of these perfectly suit the peanut butter. One taste and you will never want another brand of peanut butter whiskey.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $21 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

14. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made By Barrel & Banter

This brand of whiskey makes one of the best peanut butter whiskeys on the market. It has a perfectly balanced yet sophisticated flavor. But what makes this whiskey special is that it does not rely on sweetness to make it tasty.

The oaky notes add another layer of depth to this alcoholic beverage that makes it that much more decadent.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $20 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

15. Peanut Butter Whiskey Made by Sqrrl

The balance of chocolate and peanut butter that this whiskey has really is quite splendid. This drink is perfectly balanced and 100% delicious. You will not be able to get enough of this fragrant and delicious peanut butter whiskey. So make sure to try it out when you get the chance.

But how much does this delicious peanut butter whiskey actually cost?

• Average price – This peanut butter whiskey costs about $17 per 750ml.

Well, the price may vary greatly depending on where you get it. So make sure to consider that before you actually purchase this brand of peanut butter whiskey.

Frequently Asked Questions

Before you purchase any of these delicious peanut butter whiskey brands, there are likely a few things that you need to know before you do so. In this section we are going to answer some of your most frequently asked questions on the topic.

So, without further ado, let us dive right in and start answering your questions!

What is Peanut Butter Good With?

When you are making mixers, peanut butter whiskey works best with acidic, bubbly, and bitter ingredients. This is because these intense flavors cut through the sweetness. What specific ingredients you use depends on what you like.

So, if you want to make something fun make sure to look up some of the delicious cocktail recipes that include peanut butter whiskey. There are quite a few out there that we have found.

Is Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Actually Whiskey?

Skrewball whiskey is not technically whiskey. It is in fact a flavored liquor that has a tasty storing peanut butter flavor. If it were to be whiskey it would need to contain a minimum of 40% ABV or more. However, Skrewball peanut butter whiskey only has about 35% ABV.

Does Soda Mix Well with Peanut Butter Whiskey?

It depends on what soda you are using. We recommend that you try using Ginger Ale as it has a wonderful flavor which works well with this kind of whiskey. Throw in a tasty little wedge of lemon and you have a drink even a king would love.

Final Thoughts

We hope that you have enjoyed reading this article and learning about these amazing peanut butter whiskey brands. Each of these brands will have different price points and flavors. SO which one is really the best will be entirely dependent on what you prefer as a person.

Your preference is likely different from the person next to you. So, the best you can do when you have so many amazing drinks to choose from is to try a few that you think sound like something you would like.

With all of that said, we hope that you have a wonderful day. Good luck finding a good peanut butter whiskey that you like. There is bound to be one that suits your tastes. Goodbye for now!